Sponsored by Keenya Kelly of If You Create It. Helping creators grow and monetize on social media.
Classic Banana Pudding
Disclaimer: This post may contain affiliate links.
Please review the terms.
No oven, no stress, and two kinds of cookies. Banana pudding just met its match.
Featured Creator
Lorenzo Espada
Why You Need to Make This
Not every great dessert needs an oven, and this banana pudding is proof of that.
The no-bake format is one of the first things worth mentioning here because it genuinely opens this recipe up to anyone who has ever felt like dessert was out of their lane.
There are no temperatures to monitor, no timing to stress over, and no fear of pulling something out of the oven that did not turn out right. You layer, you chill, and you serve something that looks and tastes like it took far more skill than it actually did.
What sets this version apart from a standard banana pudding is the two-cookie combination.
Nilla Wafers bring that classic flavor most people already associate with this dessert, but the shortbread adds a buttery depth and a slightly different texture that makes the whole thing feel more layered in every sense of the word.
Two cookies might seem like a minor addition, but each one brings something different to the layers as the pudding sets, and that difference shows up in every spoonful.
If banana pudding has always been on your list of things to try making, this is the version to start with. It is forgiving, it is crowd friendly, and it delivers every single time.
Complete the Table
This dessert fits naturally at the end of almost any Southern-inspired meal. If you are already making the Crockpot Black-Eyed Peas or the Country Fried Steak, this pudding will pair well with them.
A simple fruit salad on the side also works if you want something light alongside the pudding for guests who want a little of both.
Recommended Tools
Glass Mixing Bowl - Having a dedicated bowl for mixing the pudding filling keeps things organized before the layering begins. It also makes it easier to fold in the whipped cream without losing control of the mixture when you are working with a larger batch.
Large Rectangular Baking Dish - A wider dish gives you more surface area to work with, so each layer spreads evenly from edge to edge. More coverage across the dish also means every serving gets a little of everything rather than the last few scoops ending up with mostly pudding and no cookies.
Offset Spatula - Spreading each layer evenly across the dish without disturbing what is underneath it is harder than it sounds with a regular spoon. An offset spatula gives you the control to smooth each layer flat so the final result looks as good as it tastes.
Joi’s Kitchen Notes: Savings & Swaps
Buying Tip: Bananas ripen quickly, so buy them a few days before you plan to make this and let them sit on the counter. Slightly overripe bananas are sweeter and more flavorful in a pudding than ones that are still firm and green at the edges.
Spice Savings: A little vanilla extract is really the only additional flavoring this pudding needs. A mid-range pure vanilla extract works just as well as the pricier options in a no-bake recipe like this one.
You May Also Like
