Reese’s Stuffed Cookie

Featured Creator

Sugar Spiced Dreams

Recommended Tools for This Recipe

• Cookie Scoop: Useful for portioning the dough into equal sizes so every cookie bakes at the same rate.

• Baking Sheet: A heavy-gauge pan distributes heat consistently to ensure the cookies bake through to the center.

• Glass Mixing Bowl: A large bowl gives you enough room to fold in the dough ingredients without spilling.

Why You Need to Make This Recipe

A cookie with a surprise inside is the kind of thing that nobody at the table sees coming, and everybody loves.

These are the cookies that disappear first off the platter.

The dough wraps around a chocolate-peanut butter center and bakes into something that looks like a regular cookie on the outside but delivers a soft, melty middle the moment you bite in. That contrast is what makes them so hard to stop at just one.

The one step that makes the biggest difference is chilling the dough before it goes into the oven.

I know it feels like an extra step, but it keeps the cookies thick and prevents them from spreading flat on the pan. It is the difference between a cookie that holds its shape and one that loses the center you worked to put in there.

This is also one of those recipes that look more impressive than they are.

Bring these to any gathering and watch how fast the plate clears. Nobody has to know how simple they were to make.

Complete the Table

These cookies are a dessert on their own and do not need much company. A cold glass of milk is the most obvious pairing and, honestly, the best one.

If you are putting together a dessert spread, they pair well with simple vanilla ice cream or a bowl of fresh strawberries.

The contrast between something cool and light next to a warm, stuffed cookie makes the whole thing feel a little more intentional without any extra effort.

Joi’s Kitchen Notes: Savings & Swaps

• Buying Tip: Look for seasonal sales after holidays when peanut butter candies are often discounted by half.

• Budgeting Tip: Making these from scratch is significantly cheaper than buying bakery-style cookies and offers better quality control.

• Swap Tip: If you want a different flavor, swap the chocolate peanut butter cups for caramel-filled chocolates or white chocolate chunks.

[Grab the Recipe and Watch the Full Video Here]